Dissertation
LEVELING THE COMPETITION: THE IMPACT OF TIER-BASED LEADERBOARDS ON EMPLOYEE MOTIVATION AND PERFORMANCE
Washington State University
Doctor of Philosophy (PhD), Washington State University
05/2025
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.7273/000007326
Abstract
Motivating employees at different positions within a firm’s performance management system poses a problem for management. Prior research indicates that motivating high-positioned individuals often comes at the expense of low-positioned individuals, or vice versa. In this study, I examine how the type of leaderboard (tier-based versus list-based) and the position on the leaderboard (low versus middle versus high) influence motivation and performance. Specifically, I am interested in the psychological effects of having a high, middle, or low position on a firm leaderboard and how individuals respond to firms using a tier-based leaderboard structure versus a list-based leaderboard structure. My theory suggests that tier-based leaderboards alter the field of comparison for individuals and allow them to make social comparisons at a more homogeneous level of perceived skill. In turn, tier-based leaderboards could lead to high motivation and performance for individuals, specifically high-positioned and low-positioned individuals who can exhibit demotivation when a list-based leaderboard is used. I conduct an experiment to test my predictions and theory. In line with my predictions, tier-based leaderboards result in significantly higher motivation when an employee is positioned either high or low on the leaderboard. Furthermore, individuals in low positions also exhibit higher performance with a tier-based leaderboard. I perform a follow-up experiment to better examine my proposed theory. Results support my theory that tier-based leaderboards lead individuals to assess that they are comparing themselves to peers with a similar level of skill. In addition, my tests of theory indicate that this perception is premised on individuals viewing tier-based leaderboards as a fairer system of comparison and to reducing feelings related to giving up on competitions. Overall, my study and theory provide new insights for academics and practitioners and extend prior research.
Metrics
106 File views/ downloads
11 Record Views
Details
- Title
- LEVELING THE COMPETITION
- Creators
- Adam William Bross
- Contributors
- Ryan D Sommerfeldt (Co-Chair)Bernard Wong-On-Wing (Co-Chair)Mary K Harris (Committee Member)Seung Kyo Ahn (Committee Member)
- Awarding Institution
- Washington State University
- Academic Unit
- Carson College of Business
- Theses and Dissertations
- Doctor of Philosophy (PhD), Washington State University
- Publisher
- Washington State University
- Number of pages
- 145
- Identifiers
- 99901221152701842
- Language
- English
- Resource Type
- Dissertation